ocgOpen Cognitive Graph · CDC v2.1

Education/student-diagnosis

Student answer → diagnosis card

AI grades reasoning level with four evidence rules

DxD = language_reading4 rules · L1–L4

01

Problem

On the same reading question, most answers say “agree” or “partly agree.” Asking a model to grade them yields a score and a comment. Neither says where each answer's reasoning stops, so there is no basis for what to teach next.

QuestionSomeone says, “Xiaohua gets good grades because he doesn't stay up late.” Do you agree? Support your judgment with information from the passage.

02

Generation only

Manual grading

Points per key idea. The result is a score; the reasoning leaves no record.

Asking a model to grade

A paragraph of feedback. The standard drifts with the prompt, and nothing ties the verdict to a rule or a quote.

03

With structure

Evidence reasoning is written as four checkable rules, each naming the signals it needs to see. The model only finds signals and quotes them verbatim; the rules decide the level.

cOne answercurrent cognition
r@Drule @ evidence reasoningrule matched, quotes extracted
C′level + teaching moveupdated cognition · for review
RuleLevelNameSignals required
R-01L1Restates claimno citation + circular claim + no causal challenge
R-02L2Personal examplepersonal example + no citation + limits not seen
R-03L3Structural accountcites text + sees limits + logic incomplete
R-04L4Transfer analysiscites text + causal analysis + names the fallacy

04

Result

Pick an answer to see the full reasoning and diagnosis card once the AI runs on OCG.

step-1.input.ts
// 1. The AI receives a taskconst input = {  domain: "language_reading",  ability: "EvidenceReasoning",  question: "Someone says, “Xiaohua gets good g…",  answer: "I don't think the claim is accurat…",};