ocgOpen Cognitive Graph · CDC v2.1

Industry/agentyes

AgentYes: agents that tell applies, does not apply and unknown apart

Product knowledge as evidence-anchored records; agents judge by rule instead of inferring from product pages

AyD = child_restraint4 modes · three-state judgment · Page Standard v0.2

01

Problem

AI shopping agents are increasingly asked: my child is 2 and weighs 30 lb, can this car seat face forward? Can it go on a plane? They can only read product pages written for people and infer an answer. A child car seat is exactly where guessing is not acceptable.

survey.aircraft-use · n=100

Survey: do product pages say whether a seat can fly?

29%pages state aircraft-use status
63%pages are silent
8%undeterminable (page missing or wording unclear)
  • Of the 92 pages that could be judged, 68.5% say nothing.
  • There is no pattern: some brands state it and others do not, and even models from the same brand differ. An agent cannot learn a reliable rule.
  • The information often exists, just not on the page: for at least 4 seats the PDF manual certifies aircraft use while the product page is silent.
  • Portability copy such as “great for frequent fliers” is not a certification statement, yet it is exactly what most easily misleads an agent.

On 2026-10-07 AEGT checked the product pages of 100 child car seats (18 brands, mostly the US market; manufacturer pages first, major retailers as fallback). A page counted as stating aircraft use only if its text said so explicitly; travel-friendly marketing did not count, and neither did a linked PDF manual, because agents read the page. Anything unclear was recorded as undeterminable, never guessed.

This is a problem of how information is laid out on pages, not of the products: a silent page does not mean a seat cannot fly. The Graco 4Ever DLX page used in the demo is also silent.

02

Generation only

Product pages written for people

Conditions are scattered across marketing copy, spec tables and FAQs. What is not covered is simply absent, never marked unknown, and slogans sit next to hard limits.

An AI inferring from the page

The model reads the page and writes a fluent answer: missing conditions get a plausible guess, marketing language may be taken as fact, and nothing in the verdict points back to source text.

03

With structure

Each use mode's conditions are written as records, each bound to a domain (weight, height, age, head position…) and carrying the official sentence. The rule is fixed: a mode applies only if every condition holds; one given value outside a range means it does not apply, quoting the source; a missing required value means unknown, stating what is missing and asking, never guessing. Domains with no records, such as aircraft use, are explicitly marked blank, and marketing copy is flagged as not evidence.

Appliesevery condition holds
Does not applya given value falls outside a range: quote the source
Unknowna required value is missing, or the domain is blank: say what is missing and ask
graco-4ever-dlx · domain lattice
DomainCoverage
@weight4 recordscovered
@height3 recordscovered
@age2 recordscovered
@head-position1 recordcovered
@mode-transition1 recordcovered
@aircraft-useblank: no records boundblank
@marketing1 record, not evidencenot_evidence

The domain is part of the meaning: r@D1 ≠ r@D2. Certification for vehicle use does not imply aircraft use.

04

Result

Enter the child's weight, height and age (any subset) and see the verdict for each of the four modes. Verdicts come from the rules alone; no AI is called.

agent-map · graco-4ever-dlx · judge
Rear-facing harnessUnknown

Ask for: head position

Source“Rear-Facing Harness: 4-40 lb, head must be at least 1" below handle;”

Forward-facing harnessUnknown

Ask for: height

Source“Forward-Facing Harness: 26.5-65 lb, up to 49";”

Highback boosterDoes not apply

outside range · weight — Highback Booster: 40-100 lb

outside range · age — at least 4 years old

Source“Highback Booster: 40-100 lb, 43-57", at least 4 years old;”

Backless boosterDoes not apply

outside range · weight — Backless Booster: 40-120 lb

outside range · age — at least 4 years old

Source“Backless Booster: 40-120 lb, 43-57", at least 4 years old”

Can it be used on an airplane?Unknown

Unknown: no records are bound to @aircraft-use. The agent should say so and ask the shop via /ask, not infer.

05

Evidence and next

Other cases

Demo records are extracted from Graco's official public product page (read 2026-10-02). AEGT is not affiliated with Graco. The demo shows extraction fidelity and judgment structure only and is not safety advice; follow the product manual and local regulations.