OCG LabTask-Domain Decision System
Search evidence
Live
中文

Domain Decision Packet

schema validation layer is non-negotiable regardless of model

Back to domains
c

I need to extract structured JSON from unstructured customer feedback

r

validate@structured_data/json_extraction

C'

Sonnet 4.6 for labeled, high-volume inputs. Opus 4.8 for ambiguous fields. All pipelines require deterministic schema validation; model is not the gate.

Decision Stack

Use

schema well-defined, inputs labeled, batch volume high

claude/sonnet-4.6
Use

ambiguous inputs, implicit fields, accuracy-critical pipeline

claude/opus-4.8
Avoid

output feeds automated system without human review

openai/gpt-5.5
Verify

any production extraction pipeline

deterministic_validator

Cognitive Transitions

model layer
IDRelationActorResultOutput
CT-D6-001reject@hallucinationclaude/opus-4.8acceptedmore likely to express uncertainty than fill missing fields with invented values
CT-D6-002reject@hallucinationopenai/gpt-5.5rejectedunsuitable as sole extractor in production without downstream validation
CT-D6-003validate@schema_complianceclaude/sonnet-4.6boundedreliable for labeled inputs; hallucination increases on ambiguous or unlabeled fields
E-D6-001bounded

Opus 4.8 hallucination rate significantly lower than GPT-5.5

E-GLOBAL-003
E-D6-002uncertain

Sonnet 4.6 reliable for well-defined schemas with explicit markers

inferred from instruction-following improvements