OCG LabTask-Domain Decision System
Search evidence
Live
中文

Domain Decision Packet

numerical verification against source is mandatory regardless of model

Back to domains
c

I need to extract revenue and margin data from 20 quarterly reports

r

reconcile@structured_data/financial_table_extraction

C'

Opus 4.8 for cross-report reconciliation and audit-quality work. Sonnet 4.6 for structured batch extraction. All numbers must be verified against source; no model is the final gate.

Decision Stack

Use

tables are structured, headers explicit, batch volume high

claude/sonnet-4.6
Use

cross-report reconciliation, implicit values, audit-quality required

claude/opus-4.8
Avoid

numbers feed into any automated financial calculation

openai/gpt-5.5
Verify

any financial extraction for reporting or audit

human

Cognitive Transitions

model layer
IDRelationActorResultOutput
CT-D10-001reconcile@numerical_consistencyclaude/opus-4.8acceptedappropriate for cross-report reconciliation and financial citation precision
CT-D10-002locate@cell_valueclaude/sonnet-4.6boundedmatches Opus on structured tables with headers; weaker on cross-table implicit values
CT-D10-003reconcile@numerical_consistencyopenai/gpt-5.5rejectedhigh hallucination rate makes numerical outputs unreliable for financial use without full verification
E-D10-001bounded

Opus 4.8 Finance Agent v2: highest score among tested models

E-GLOBAL-006
E-D10-002bounded

Opus 4.8 delivers better citation precision and token efficiency on financial document workflows

Anthropic Opus 4.8 launch, May 2026
E-D10-003bounded

Sonnet 4.6 matches Opus on OfficeQA which includes table reading

E-GLOBAL-005
E-D10-004bounded

GPT-5.5 hallucination rate 86% makes it unreliable for numerical extraction without verification

E-GLOBAL-003